SpinnachBuying guides that show their work.

Comparing auto insurance quotes line by line

A cheaper quote is only cheaper if it buys the same coverage. Here are the parts of an auto policy, the inputs that change a price, and what to confirm before you switch.

Bring this to the call

CompareOption AOption BOption C
Bodily injury and property damage liability limits
Collision and comprehensive: included or not, and each deductible
Uninsured / underinsured motorist coverage
Drivers, vehicles and mileage each quote assumed
Company and agent license status in your state

Blank on purpose. Fill it in from each company’s written terms — we don’t score options for you.

The parts of a policy

An auto policy is a bundle of separate coverages. Bodily injury liability protects you against claims from other people injured in an accident you cause (NAIC). Collision pays for physical damage to your car when it collides with an object, and comprehensive pays for damage from almost all other causes, including fire; the NAIC describes both as optional (NAIC). Uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage is listed as a standard part of a policy and pays if, for example, you are injured by a hit-and-run driver (NAIC).

Most states require some kind of insurance to drive legally, and the required amounts are set by each state (NAIC). Your state insurance department can tell you what applies to you (NAIC).

Making quotes comparable

The NAIC calls premium quotes a useful tool for comparing companies, and says it is crucial to give the same information to each agent or company you ask (NAIC). In practice that means the same drivers, the same vehicles, the same limits and the same deductibles on every quote, written on the worksheet above before you compare a single price.

Prices are driven by risk. The NAIC notes that drivers with previous violations or accidents are considered higher risk (NAIC). Some insurers offer usage-based insurance, which looks at driving habits such as miles driven, speed and time of day to set the cost (NAIC). If a quote includes one of these programs, ask what data is collected and how it can change your price.

Before you switch

Confirm that both the company and the agent are licensed to do business in your state (NAIC). The NAIC points consumers to its Consumer Insurance Search for company complaint, license and financial information (NAIC). You can run the search at the NAIC's site (NAIC). Keep your old policy in force until the new one is issued in writing.

Before you sign, ask

  • Did every quote use the same drivers, vehicles and coverage limits?
  • Is the company licensed in my state, and is the agent?
  • What discounts were applied, and what do I have to do to keep them?
  • Does the quote include any usage-based (driving data) program?
  • What changes at renewal?

Sources

  1. NAIC — Auto insurance consumer guidecontent.naic.org
  2. NAIC — Consumer resourcescontent.naic.org
  3. NAIC Consumer Insurance Searchcontent.naic.org
  4. NAIC — Get insurance help from your state insurance departmentcontent.naic.org

Optional · paid offer

Auto insurance quotes

Request auto insurance quotes for the same drivers, cars and coverage so they can be compared line by line.

Get this guide’s offer

Spinnach may be paid if you respond to this offer. It is shown because it matches this guide’s topic, not because of anything in the guide above. Disclosure.

Spinnach editors research and write Spinnach guides from public sources. This guide is general information, not legal, tax, medical or financial advice. Confirm every term in writing with the company before you sign. Found an error? editors@spinnach.com.