Replacement cost vs actual cash value in a homeowners policy
Two home insurance quotes can value the same loss very differently. Here is how valuation, deductibles and the flood and earthquake exclusions change what a policy pays.
Bring this to the call
| Compare | Option A | Option B | Option C |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dwelling valuation: replacement cost or actual cash value | |||
| Dwelling coverage amount vs your estimated rebuild cost | |||
| Deductible on each quote | |||
| Flood and earthquake: excluded, and what separate coverage costs | |||
| A current home inventory |
Blank on purpose. Fill it in from each company’s written terms — we don’t score options for you.
Two ways to value a loss
Replacement cost is the amount it would take to replace or rebuild your home, while actual cash value is the amount it would take to repair or replace the damage after depreciation (NAIC). On an older roof or older belongings, the gap between those two numbers can be large, so the valuation basis belongs on your comparison before the price does.
The NAIC says it is important to insure your home for at least 80 percent of its replacement value (NAIC). Ask each insurer how it estimated the rebuild amount on your quote.
Deductibles
The deductible is the amount you pay out of pocket on each claim, and a policy with a lower deductible costs more than one with a higher deductible (NAIC). Compare quotes at the same deductible, then decide separately how much of a claim you could pay yourself.
What a standard policy leaves out
Flood damage from ground water, rain runoff and snow-melt is not covered by a standard policy, and flood coverage has to come from the National Flood Insurance Program or a private insurer (NAIC). The federal flood program's own site says most homeowners insurance does not cover flood damage (FloodSmart.gov). No standard policy, including the homeowners policy, covers catastrophic earthquake damage either (NAIC).
Keep an inventory
The NAIC recommends a home inventory as a way to decide how much coverage fits your situation, stored somewhere safe and easy to reach online (NAIC). It also suggests checking with your agent at least once a year that the policy still provides adequate coverage (NAIC). Before you buy, look the company up in the NAIC's Consumer Insurance Search (NAIC).
Before you sign, ask
- Is the dwelling covered at replacement cost or actual cash value?
- How was the rebuild amount estimated?
- Does my area call for separate flood coverage, and when would it take effect?
- Are there separate deductibles for any specific perils?
- Is the company licensed in my state?
Sources
- NAIC — Homeowners insurance consumer guidecontent.naic.org
- FloodSmart.gov — National Flood Insurance Programfloodsmart.gov
- NAIC Consumer Insurance Searchcontent.naic.org
Optional · paid offer
Home insurance quotes
Request homeowners insurance quotes and compare valuation, deductibles and exclusions.
Get this guide’s offerSpinnach may be paid if you respond to this offer. It is shown because it matches this guide’s topic, not because of anything in the guide above. Disclosure.
Spinnach editors research and write Spinnach guides from public sources. This guide is general information, not legal, tax, medical or financial advice. Confirm every term in writing with the company before you sign. Found an error? editors@spinnach.com.